Why Willpower Isn’t Enough (and What Works Better)

Let’s be honest: how many times have we told ourselves, “This time I’ll have more willpower”?

Whether it’s the new diet, a commitment to cut sugar, a promise to stop late-night snacking, or a well-intentioned grocery list, we often approach change like a battle of sheer determination. But here’s the truth:

Willpower is not the problem. And it’s not the solution either.

It’s not that you’re weak. It’s not that you “lack discipline.” It’s not that other people have some magical reservoir of self-control that you missed out on. It’s that we’ve been sold a myth about how change actually works.

Let’s unpack that.

Willpower Is a Finite Resource

The idea that we can white-knuckle our way through temptation is actually outdated—and science backs it up.

Researchers in psychology have discovered that willpower behaves like a muscle. According to studies by Dr. Roy Baumeister and colleagues, willpower can become depleted throughout the day. This phenomenon is called ego depletion. When you’re tired, stressed, or hungry, your ability to make good decisions drops dramatically.

Ever notice how much easier it is to say “no” to a cookie at 10 a.m. than at 10 p.m.?

Or how your best-laid plans to “just buy healthy food” at the grocery store fall apart when you’re running on fumes?

Willpower isn’t endless—and it was never meant to be your only strategy.

Stress + Hunger = Decision Disaster

Recently, I attended the memorial service of the sister of a lifelong friend. This friend—someone who helped shape who I am—has been a steady thread in the fabric of my life, even though time and distance have made our catch-ups more occasional than either of us would like.

Her sister, just a year older than us and someone I once shared an apartment in college and late-night conversations with, died unexpectedly. Way too young. The kind of loss that makes you feel like the world is slightly off its axis.

The service was beautiful and emotional. Seeing my friend again—hugging her, looking in her eyes, feeling the weight of her grief—was both comforting and heartbreaking. My heart ached. My spirit felt heavy. I was emotionally raw in a way that felt bone-deep.

After the memorial, I decided to stop by a grocery store nearby—one I love but rarely get to visit since it’s about an hour from where I live. I just needed two things: eggs and bread. That was it. A simple, focused errand.

But I walked out with eggs, bread… and a box of lemon cookies. And a little tub of fruit jellies. And a few other impulse snacks that definitely weren’t on my list. If we’re being honest, I don’t think I even looked at the ingredients or prices—I just floated through those aisles like a woman on auto-pilot, guided more by my emotions than my grocery goals.

As soon as I got in the car, I opened the box and ate a cookie.

Was I hungry? Maybe a little. Was I sad? Definitely. Did I need cookies? Well… not really.

But in that moment, I wasn’t eating because I was physically hungry—I was eating to soothe something tender. Something tired. Something human.

I know better than to grocery shop in that frame of mind. Yet, there I was.

And that’s exactly the kind of moment where willpower doesn’t stand a chance.

That story? That’s not a failure of character.

It’s biology.

When you’re hungry, your blood sugar drops, impairing your brain’s prefrontal cortex—the very part that’s responsible for impulse control and long-term planning.

When you’re stressed, your body pumps out cortisol, your “fight-or-flight” hormone. It overrides logic in favor of survival. And survival, for your body, often looks like eat whatever’s fast, fatty, or sweet.

Add those two forces together—hunger and stress—and you’ve got a perfect storm. No wonder that bag of chips or cookies ends up in your cart. It’s not weakness. It’s chemistry.

Why the "Try Harder" Approach Keeps Failing

Our culture glorifies grit and hustle. So when we struggle with food or habits, we tend to think the answer is to just try harder.

But let’s zoom out.

You wouldn’t expect your phone battery to last all day without a charge. You wouldn’t expect your car to run without gas. You wouldn’t expect a child to sit still and behave perfectly with no sleep or snacks.

But we often expect ourselves to make wise, thoughtful, healthy choices 24/7—while running on empty emotionally, physically, spiritually, and socially.

Here’s the good news: Change is possible. But it doesn’t come from shame, striving, or superhuman self-control.

So What Does Work?

Instead of relying on willpower, we can set ourselves up for success by tapping into something much more sustainable: structure, self-awareness, and support.

1. Structure

Make the right choice the easy choice. Not because you’re weak, but because you’re wise.

·         Keep nourishing food stocked at home.

·         Don’t grocery shop when you’re hungry (learned that one the hard way, right?).

·         Plan for pleasure on purpose so it doesn’t sneak up on you with a side of guilt.

2. Self-Awareness

Start noticing your patterns without judgment.

·         Are there times of day when you’re more vulnerable to stress-eating?

·         Do certain emotions send you to the pantry?

·         Is perfectionism tripping you up again?

Becoming aware isn’t about control—it’s about choice.

When you recognize what’s going on in your body, your mind, and your heart, you can respond with curiosity instead of criticism.

3. Support

Let’s be real—change is harder when we do it alone.

Whether it’s a coach, a trusted friend, or a like-minded community, having support helps you stay grounded when willpower fades. Encouragement is powerful. Accountability is motivating. And compassion is contagious.

In fact, research from Stanford shows that people are significantly more likely to stick to health-related changes when they have regular support from another person. It’s not a sign of weakness—it’s how we’re wired.

Freedom Is Found in Grace, Not Grit

At the end of the day, willpower can get you started—but it won’t carry you through.

What you really need isn’t more pressure to perform. It’s permission to pause. To breathe. To listen to your body and honor your needs. To set up rhythms and routines that serve you instead of stressing you out. To ditch shame and embrace compassion. To ask for help, receive grace, and start again as many times as it takes.

So next time you catch yourself thinking, “If I only had more willpower…” Pause. Ask yourself instead:

What am I feeling right now?

That’s the beginning of real, lasting change.

Willpower is like a match—it can light the fire, but it can’t keep it burning. For that, you need fuel, support, and a lot of grace.

What if we stopped striving to control ourselves and started learning to care for ourselves?

That’s where transformation really begins.

If you'd like support in your transformation, comment SUPPORT below, and I'll message you so we can figure out together how I can best support you.

If this post resonated with you, please consider sharing it to spread the word. It might be of use to someone you know.

If you’d like to learn more about this topic, click HERE to book a session with me, or follow me on Facebook @Nourishing Body & Soul or on Instagram @tlastle.nourishingbodyandsoul